If we know Hydroxychloroquine doesn't work, why are scientists still experimenting with it?


Title (Dublin Core)

If we know Hydroxychloroquine doesn't work, why are scientists still experimenting with it?

Description (Dublin Core)

My husband was exposed to COVID-19 by a co-worker from a different branch. She took the COVID-19 test, but instead of quarantining like you’re supposed to, she continued running errands. One of those errands was going to the bank, where my husband works and making a withdrawal. That same day she got her test results and called to let him know. OK, I feel a lot of things about that, annoyed. I’m really annoyed and frustrated that she believed she had COVID, went to the lengths to get tested, but didn’t self-quarantine. My husband is more empathetic. He thinks she had urgent things to do and no one to help her. OK, that’s the first part of this story. The second part, is that suddenly on FB I saw an advertisement for a research trial on COVID. I filled it out for my husband, and a few days later he got an email offering him the chance to participate in a study. I read the fine print, it seemed sketch. First, the trial is for 4,000 people to take Hydroxychloroquine, a malaria drug that we know doesn’t work. Second, the compensation is only $300 total. That seems like a really, really low sum to be a guinea pig. Third, the way that the researchers phrased his options bothered me.

On the consent form it lists his choices:
“Your other options: There are currently no approved treatments to prevent infection or COVIF-19 symptoms for people who have had contact with an infected person. You do not have to participate in this study.

Your other choices may include:
• Taking part in another study
• Getting no PEP after contact with a suspected or confirmed case of COVID-19.”

This seems far from neutral, and actually to me- sounds like a combination of pressure/fear to get people to participate. This is my first time seeing an informed consent form, and I wonder if they’re all this loaded in terms of trying to manipulate someone into donating their health and body to an experimental process.

The study was run by the NYU Grossman School of Medicine and the University of Washington.
NYU, University of Washington, COVID research, medical ethics, Hydroxychloroquine

Date (Dublin Core)

July 21, 2020

Creator (Dublin Core)

Katy Kole de Peralta

Contributor (Dublin Core)

Katy Kole de Peralta

Type (Dublin Core)


Controlled Vocabulary (Dublin Core)

English Science
English Education--Universities
English Health & Wellness

Curator's Tags (Omeka Classic)

University of Washington
medical ethics
Grossman School of Medicine
consent form

Linked Data (Dublin Core)

Date Submitted (Dublin Core)


Date Modified (Dublin Core)


Item sets

This item was submitted on August 13, 2020 by Katy Kole de Peralta using the form “Share Your Story” on the site “A Journal of the Plague Year”:

Click here to view the collected data.

New Tags

I recognize that my tagging suggestions may be rejected by site curators. I agree with terms of use and I accept to free my contribution under the licence CC BY-SA